|
"We are a crippled old ship, rushed out before our engine
room was really efficient. We are now unable to condense water quickly
enough and cannot steam more than ten knots. So we crawl south…Our
shooting was rotten." Ship’s doctor of HMS
Kent, (Castles of Steel, 2003 by
Robert K. Massie, at page 277)
|
As the French navy fell further behind the Royal Navy in construction of
battleships in the last two decades of the 19th Century, some French
officers devised ways to overcome their numerical inferiority. Called the "Jeune
Ecole" the
Young
School
, these officers thought outside of the box to develop new strategies to
overcome the British preponderance in numbers. One path was to develop small,
cheap ships that could sink expensive battleships and the torpedo boat came into
vogue. With the development and production of the new British torpedo-boat
destroyers as a type, it was thought that the Royal Navy had overcome the threat
of masses of French torpedo boats. "Given three years without
complications, I trust that in the great requirements – men, ships, and works
– the needs of this Navy for its efficient service will have been met, and the
office of the panic-mongers will be gone." (First Sea Lord
Admiral Sir Frederick Richards, February 2 1897, The Anatomy of British
Seapower, 1940, by Arthur Marder, at page 282) However, the French
had another axis in their two pronged approach.
This path was centered around the destruction of British commerce or "Guerre
de Course". The Confederate Navy had been very successful during
the American Civil War in dispatching raiders to attack Union merchant and
whaling fleets and the depredations of CSS
Alabama, CSS Shenandoah
and other raiders caused such destruction and reflagging of vessels to other
countries that the American merchant marine never recovered. However, the object
of this strategy was not to starve
Great Britain
of food imported from overseas. The target was financial. The goal was to
destroy enough merchantmen that the insurance on the rest of the merchantmen
would skyrocket and cause economic chaos in
Great Britain
. However, for the French to send out raiders against the British merchant
marine would require a different type of ship. The Royal Navy had many scout and
protected cruisers operating on the British trade routes, normally classified as
2nd rate or 3rd rate cruisers. What was needed was a ship
that could overcome a typical British trade protection cruiser. To achieve this
result cruiser designs were given an armored belt, which became the
distinguishing feature of the armored cruiser type and so began the Cult of
the Armored Cruiser.
Russia
also chose to produce large armored cruisers and it was the Russian cruisers as
well as the large French armored cruiser building program that imposed somewhat
of a panic in the Royal Navy. Scout cruisers had no armor and protected cruisers
had only an armored deck with no side armor. In theory these French and Russian
armored cruisers could shrug off hits from the British cruisers, destroy them
and continue to wreak destruction among British merchantmen. The Royal Navy had
built a handful of armored cruisers in the past but all previous designs were
slow and had other significant defects. As the year 1897 went into the spring,
the complacency of their Lordships of the Admiralty was disturbed by a new
French building program.
France
had already started building armored cruisers when she ordered six more armored
cruisers with another for 1898, plus three corsair cruisers, unarmored but very
fast (23 knot) ships specifically designed to destroy commerce.
"On May 1, 1897 the D.N.I. prepared a memorandum on the new French
cruiser policy. Everything, he remarked, pointed to the creation by
France
of a class of vessels superior to those which formed the bulk of their foreign
or trade protecting squadrons in war." (The Anatomy of
British Seapower, 1940, by Arthur Marder, at page 284) The
alarm bells had sounded in the hallowed halls of the Admiralty. What the Royal
Navy needed were armored cruisers with sufficient speed, armor and gun power to
overcome the French and Russian designs. "Under construction we have
twenty armoured cruisers. In the Fleet at present we can number no modern
vessels of this important type, though
France
and
Russia
have added many to their navies in the past few years. When it was decided to
follow in the footsteps of our two rivals, Lord Goschen did not fail to confide
to the House of Commons that the need for these ships was urgent, and that no
effort should be spared to add as many of them as was necessary to the Fleet at
the earliest possible moment. Early in the summer of 1897 the first four of the
Cressy class, of 12,000 tons, were provided for in the Supplementary Estimate."
(Naval Annual 1901, The Past Five Years’
Warship-Building by Archibald S. Hurd, at page 261-262)
The first class of new armored cruisers was the Cressy
class. Comprised of six ships, the Cresseys
could easily be distinguished by the multitude of J-shape funnels blooming from
their decks. Armed with two 9.2-inch and twelve 6-inch guns, they seemed to be
adequately armed but they were too slow. With a top speed of 21 knots, it would
be difficult to run down opposing cruisers of similar speed. The next class
addressed that need. The four Drake
class were huge ships at the time. Displacing over 14,000 tons and armed with
two 9.2-inch and sixteen 6-inch guns, these ships were fast with a top speed of
23-knots but they were expensive and required crews significantly larger than
contemporary British battleships because of their large increase in machinery.
What was needed was a class of armored cruisers that were smaller, more
economical to build and more economical to man to be built in quantity. The
solution was the
County
Class
armored cruiser. Compared to the preceding Drake
class, the ships of the County
class were 1/3 smaller in displacement, shorter, had a thinner armored belt, and
reduced the guns carried. The armament was fourteen 6-inch guns with four
mounted in twin turrets and five mounted per side in casemates. However, they
were not to sacrifice speed as they were also designed for a top speed of 23
knots.

Profile, Plan & Quarter View |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
"If in the battleship classes other navies have followed our lead,
in the Cressy class we have followed the example of the Russian and other navies
by adopting the belt for the protection of the vitals of the ship, instead of
depending, as we have done hitherto, on a protective deck." (The
Naval Annual 1899, 1899, Recent Warship Construction by T.A.
Brassey, Chapter VI, at page 182) In the same volume appeared the text of
the First Lord’s Memorandum of March 7, 1899. After describing the armored
cruisers of the Cressy and Drake
classes, First Lord George J. Goschen mentioned a new class of cruiser. "Two
other cruisers were included in the Supplemental Programme. They will be of a
new design, and tenders have been invited for their construction. Their
principal features are as follows: - Length between perpendiculars, 440 ft. ;
breath, extreme, 66 ft.; mean draught, 24 ½ ft.; displacement, 9,800 tons;
speed (with natural draught), 23 knots; I.H.P., 22,000. Armament: fourteen 6-in.
Q.-F. guns, four in turrets, ten in casemates; ten 12-pdr. Q.-F. guns, three
3-pdr., two torpedo tubes. The 6-in. guns will be of the latest type, and will
be protected by armour about 4-in. thick. Vertical side armour of the same
thickness will be carried over a considerable portion of the length, with
thinner armour on the bows. Strong protective decks will be associated with this
side armour." (The Naval Annual 1899, 1899, First Lord’s
Memorandum by George J. Goschen First Lord of the Admiralty, at page 424)
The London Times was enthusiastic over the new, smaller cruiser
design. They were specifically compared against the protected cruisers of the Diadem
class. "These remarkable cruisers are to be 440 ft. in length and 66
ft. in breadth, with their displacement of 9,800 tons, and will be armed with
fourteen 6-in. Q.F. guns, ten of which will be in casemate, and two forward and
two aft on twin mountings. They will also have six 12-pr. Q.F. guns amidships on
the main deck, and two forward and two aft on the upper deck. Thus, on a
1,00-ton less displacement they will be provided with two fewer 6-in. and four
fewer 12-pr. Guns than the Diadem class; but they will have many compensating
advantages, as not only will they be armoured, but they will have a speed of 23
knots, against 20 ½ knots in the Diadems." (Naval Annual
1900, page 15) However, within a few years, as the first two
ships underwent trials, it was discovered that the design calculations were not
met.
Although designed for 23-knots, the initial ships of the County class did not
live up to their design. "The County class includes ten ships of 9800
tons, and six of 10,700 tons displacement. The estimated speed of the former is
23 knots with 22,000 I.H.P. They have so far failed to attain their contract
speed, although the designed horse-power has been exceeded. The failure has been
attributed to the unsuitability of the propellers. The changes made in the
propellers of the
Kent
has not had the desired effect, , though better results may still be attained. "
(Naval Annual 1903, page 5) Tests at full power
reported
Bedford
with a speed of 22.7-knots at full power of 22,457ihp, while
Kent
was a knot slower with 21.7-knots at full power of 22,249ihp. The new
propellers only increased the speed of
Kent
to 21.89-knots. The 1903 Annual also stated, "The weakness of these
ships is in their waterline protection." In the armor section the
belt armor of the County class is criticized. "Even the Monmouth,
with her 4-in. belt, which can be riddled by the 6.4-in. French gun at nearly
5,000 yards range, has a 1 ¼-in. main deck some 60 ft. broad, the weight of
which would have allowed the belt and casemates to be sufficiently thickened to
make the vitals and guns safe from the 6.4-in. shot until the ships closed to
1500 yds. And the smallest gun by which the Monmouth is likely to be attacked is
the 5.5-in., which will pierce her belt and casemates at over 3000 yds. As in
the battleships, were the armour removed from the main belt, there is nothing
that could be materially injured by pieces of shell passing downwards through a
thin deck, whilst the top of the belt is so high above the water that there
would be little trouble owing to admission of water. It will be very poor
satisfaction to the stokers, who, whilst tending the fires, will run the
greatest risk from splinters of shot which are liable to enter the stokehold,
after piercing belt and ‘armoured’ deck (3/4-in.!), to learn that their
clothes, which are stowed immediately beneath the main deck, are safe from the
effect of bursting shells….It may not be too late to transfer some of the
comparatively useless plating of the main deck of the County class to the slopes
of the lower deck. The 4-in. belt can scarcely be modified, but would it not be
possible to substitute 5-in. for 4-in. casemates in the ships which are not to
be completed till next year?" (Naval Annual 1903, page 353)
Kent and Essex
were ordered in the supplementary estimates for 1898-1899 with Monmouth
and Bedford closely following in
the 1899-1900 Program and the last six in the 1900-1901 Program. However, HMS
Monmouth was the first to be laid down on August 29, 1899
at the class became officially known as the Monmouth
class. As more modern designs joined the fleet, the ships of the Monmouth
class were assigned to foreign stations. In this they were fulfilling the role
originally envisioned for them, trade route protection. Because of the lack of
any guns heavier than a six-incher, Jackie Fisher commented, "Sir
William White designed the ‘County’ class but forgot the guns".
HMS Kent
was laid down at
Portsmouth
on February 12, 1900. She was the third of the class to be laid down but was
the first to be launched on March 6, 1901. She also was the first to be
completed on October 1, 1903.
The armored cruiser craze lasted less than a decade for by 1906 a new type of
warship appeared that ended construction of the armored cruiser. This was the
battlecruiser. Although HMS Invincible
was originally typed as an armored cruiser, her 12-inch gun main armament
clearly eclipsed the previous cruiser designs and after a few years the term
battlecruiser was coined to describe this new type. Armored cruisers only years
old had suddenly became as obsolescent in the face of the Invincible
as the predreadnought battleships became with the arrival of HMS
Dreadnought. Before long many were placed in reserve, especially
the older types. With the coming of World War One they were dusted off and sent
back to sea with reserve crews and HMS Kent
was one of these.
When
Japan
joined the allies against
Germany
, her primary goal was to seize the German possessions in
Asia
. One prize was the port of Tsing-Tao in
China
, which was home of the German Asiatic Squadron. Commanded by Admiral Graf von
Spee, this force was composed of two excellent armored cruisers, Scharnhorst
and Gneisenau, as well as five
scout cruisers. Although this was a formidable force with superbly trained
crews, it certainly was no match for the entire Imperial Japanese Navy. Von Spee
steamed out of port and disappeared into the Pacific. The Royal Navy and
Japanese Navy sent out squadrons to locate the Asiatic Squadron and Kit
Cradock’s cruisers were assigned the
South Atlantic
. Cradock wanted the modern armored cruiser HMS
Defence assigned to strengthen his squadron but th is was refused
and Cradock was ordered to reconnoiter the coast of Chile in the Pacific. So off
went Kit with Good Hope, Monmouth,
the scout cruiser Glasgow and
auxiliary cruiser Otranto. He
also had the predreadnought battleship
Canopus
but it was reported to Cradock that she was only capable of twelve knots. This
was unfortunate, because this old battleship was capable of sixteen knots. Based
on the faulty information about
Canopus
, Cradock left the battleship behind in his search for von Spee. On October 31,
1914 Cradock met von Spee 50 miles west of the Chilean
port
of
Coronel
. As night was falling both of Cradock’s cruisers were reduced to wrecks. Good
Hope blew up in the night but a critically damaged Monmouth
broke contact with the German armored cruisers and tried to struggle to safety.
However, she was discovered by the light cruiser SMS
Nurnburg. The light cruiser pumped 75 4-inch shells into Monmouth
until she capsized.
While her sistership was succumbing to German fire, HMS
Kent was cruising peacefully off another continent, preparing for
another dawn.
Kent
had been assigned the duty of patrolling off of the west coast of
Africa
. She had only been put back into service at the start of October and 3/5ths of
her crew were reservists. In crossing the
Bay of Biscay
in mid-October, half the crew was seasick. As the Admiralty first learned of
the disaster of
Colonel
,
Kent
was off the coast of
Sierra Leone
. She was immediately ordered to join the South Atlantic squadron at Albrolhos
Rock off of
Brazil
. On November 28, 1914 the squadron now under the command of Rear Admiral
Sturdee who had arrived with the battle cruisers on November 26. All of the
ships needed firing practice but especially the older armored cruisers, which
had put to sea with scratch crews. On November 30 the squadron had firing
practice and
Kent
and Carnarvon took turns towing
targets for each other.
Kent
expended 144 rounds in an attempt to sharpen her gunner’s skills. Sturdee’s
squadron arrived at the
Falkland Islands
late on December 7. The squadron needed coaling so all of the big ships, except
Kent
went to the outer
harbor
of
Port William
and shut down their boilers for maintenance and coaling.
Kent
was tasked to stay in the outer harbor with her steam up. She had been
designated as a sentry. The auxiliary cruiser
Macedonia
had the duty until 08:00 December 8 and
Kent
was ordered to relieve her that morning. That morning would bring von Spee
instead.
Von Spee at 5:30 a.m. had detached Gneisenau
and Nurnberg to reconnoiter the
Port Stanley
and Port William anchorages. The weather, which was normally misty, rainy or
occluded with sleet or snow in the area of the
Falklands
was abnormally clear and bright that morning. The Germans were sighted at more
than ten miles from Sapper Hill. At 8:45 the smoke of the rest of the German
squadron was reported as coming up behind the first two ships. When the Germans
were spotted Sturdee ordered
Kent
to cover the harbor entrance, cover
Macedonia
and observe the Germans until the British force could get steam up and leave
harbor. As the
Kent
neared the harbor entrance, smoke from the two German ships could be seen over
a spit of land. The Gneisenau
had spotted the
Kent
leaving harbor and it was thought the cruiser was trying to escape. As Gneisenau
was steering towards
Kent
to engage, a round hit her from an unseen assailant, the
Canopus
. Because the
Kent
hadn’t fired and the Germans were well outside the range of the six-inch guns
on the
County
Class
cruiser, it was guessed that there was something big and dangerous in the
harbor. With the hit the Germans turned to rejoin the rest of their squadron.
Without this hit the Germans had the opportunity to close the British force.
They certainly could have overwhelmed the
Kent
and perhaps damage the immobile ships sufficiently to allow the German squadron
to escape.
The solitary
Kent
was finally joined by the light cruiser Glasgow
at 0945. At 0950 the rest of Sturdee’s squadron weighed anchor and headed for
sea. However, it would not be until 10:30 that they were assembled and ready for
pursuit. When the squadron took off after the German Asiatic Squadron, it was
lead by
Glasgow
, followed by
Kent
. However, it was not long before the battle cruisers passed the old armored
cruiser. Sturdee signaled "General Chase" and the HMS
Kent responded magnificently. A disappointment on her trials and
known as the slowest of the Counties, the stokers of the
Kent
worked wonders.
Kent
was ordered to fall back and take station off the port quarter of Invincible.
Kent
proved to be the fastest of the armored cruisers that morning as the Carnarvon
limped along at 18-knots and
Cornwall
managed 22-knots. At 12:20 Sturdee opened the engagement with his battle
cruisers. Aboard Inflexible
cheers could be heard coming from
Kent
as the battle cruisers opened fire.
Kent
had to bide her time as the range was too great for her 6-inch battery. For an
hour it was the two British battle cruisers against the two German armored
cruisers, as all of the other ships were outside of gunnery range. At 1320 von
Spee saw that he could not shake the battle cruisers, so he ordered his light
cruisers to break away and escape. His armored cruisers would engage the British
to allow the lighter ships a chance to survive.
As the German light cruisers separated from the heavier ships, the British
followed the battle plan that had been established more than a week before. That
plan called for the battle cruisers to take on the Scharnhorst
and Gneisenau and the other
British cruisers to tackle the German light cruisers. Following this plan
Glasgow
,
Kent
and
Cornwall
took off after the three German light cruisers,
Leipzig
, Nurnberg and
Dresden
. At this point the Germans had a ten to twelve mile lead. The sluggish Carnarvon,
ten miles behind, continued trudging after the battle cruisers. For more than
two hours the armored cruisers chased the lighter German ships. Only
Glasgow
possessed the speed to close quickly but she couldn’t take on three cruisers
at once. The German ships would have been faster but after four months at sea
their hulls were foul and their machinery creaky from constant use. At 15:45 the
German cruisers parted from each other.
Dresden
, the lead ship turned southwest, Nurnberg
turned east and the trailing
Leipzig
continued on the original southern course. It was decided that two birds in the
hand were worth three in the bush and the
Dresden
was not followed as she still had a substantial lead. While
Glasgow
and
Cornwall
continued after
Leipzig
,
Kent
turned to follow
Nurnberg
.
The performance of the engine crew of HMS
Kent during her chase of
Nurnberg
was nothing short of spectacular. The
Kent
could not hit 22 knots at her
trials more than a decade earlier, when she was fresh from the builders, and yet
she had to be told to fall back by Sturdee in the general chase. By 11:00 that
morning
Kent
was already hitting the original designed speed of 23-knots. As she chased
after
Dresden
at 16:00 that afternoon the old, worn out Kent,
who could only crawl along at ten knots a month earlier, hit 24-knots, only a
knot less than the battle cruisers. Captain Allen thought that his command had
actually achieved 25-knots as her ihp was exceeded by 5,000ihp. Since
Kent
had been selected as guard ship, she had kept her steam up and not coaled. As a
result, during the chase she was short of coal. To make up for this shortage the
enthusiastic crew tore apart anything wooden to feed the fires of the ship’s
boilers. Ladders, doors, officer’s furniture, the chaplain’s lectern, the
paymaster’s desk and even deck planking went into the fires to allow
Kent
to close the distance with
Nurnberg
. However, it paid off and
Kent
closed the distance. By 17:00 the range was 11,000 yards. Nurnberg
fired with her aft 4.1-inch guns and
Kent
opened up with her forward turret guns but the shells fell short. By 17:09
Kent
was in range and fired continuously. The long range firing seemed to get no
results but at 17:35
Nurnberg
suffered a mechanical failure. The worn machinery could not take the extended
stress of operating at top speed. Two boilers burst from salt condensation and
Nurnberg
’s ability to flee disappeared.
The final engagement resembled two mismatched pugilists in a prizefight. The Nurnberg
had a lighter punch with her 4.1-inch guns but her gun crews were highly trained
through years of service on that ship and the fact that the
Dresden
was part of the best firing squadron in the German Navy. She could land punches
faster and in greater quantity. On the other hand the
Kent
was a much heavier opponent. Unlike the nimble, precise
Dresden
, which was the boxer of the two, the
Kent
was a bar room brawler. Her green gun crews could not hope to match the
precision and quickness of the German gun crews. However, her 6-inch guns were
rib crushers, capable chewing apart the light German ship if she could score
enough hits. The key to this was to get in close to punch the guts out of the
German ship. When
Kent
had trimmed the range to 7,000 yards,
Nurnberg
turned broadside to finish the duel.
Kent
with her belt armor continued to close to 3,000 yards. As
Kent
bored in, most of the German shells could not penetrate
Kent
’s armor. Contrary to the earlier observation of the
Kent
’s chaplain, the armored cruiser scored hit after hit on her lighter opponent.
However,
Nurnberg
still scored damaging hits. One shell wrecked a 6-inch casemate position and
another shell wrecked the
Kent
’s radio room. The casemate strike could have been disastrous. The 4.1-inch
shell burst upon hitting the A3 casemate and ignited charges inside the gun
position. A flash of flame followed down the ammunition handling trunk but
Sergeant Charles Mayes at the bottom of the trunk threw away the open charge at
the bottom of the trunk and flooded the compartment. Without that action Captain
Allen stated in his after action report that it was entirely possible that the
flash could have set up a chain reaction until it reached the magazine, blowing
up the ship. The Royal Navy failed to learn from this event, as the losses of RN
battle cruisers and armored cruisers to magazine explosions at
Jutland
were to prove.
The body blows of the 6-inch guns of
Kent
quickly made a shambles of
Nurnberg
. Funnels and the mainmast were lost, guns were disabled and by 18:25
Nurnberg
was dead in the water. In ten more minutes the last German gun was silenced and
Kent
ceased fire. As
Kent
waited alongside the burning
Nurnberg
, the German cruiser still flew her flag.
Kent
resumed firing at 18:57 and
Nurnberg
finally lowered her colors. "
Kent
closed in through the mist and saw the flames dancing above the light
cruiser’s deck and shooting out from portholes and jagged holes in the hull.
The rain pattering on the decks and hissing into the fires had little effect
because it was accompanied by gusts of wind that fanned the flames more than the
rain quenched them." (Castles of Steel, 2003 by
Robert K. Massie, at page 278)
Kent
patched two boats and quickly launched them to recover survivors. At 19:27 the
Nurnberg
turned over and went down by the bow. Crewmen on
Kent
threw ropes over the cruisers sides, hoping that some of the German crew could
make use of them. Searchlights illuminated the scene in an effort to increase
the odds of the British boats and German survivors sighting each other. The
water was intensely cold and seas were gathering. Hypothermia undoubtedly
rapidly ran through the ranks of German survivors. The British continued their
rescue mission past 21:00. The results were meager. Twelve Germans were rescued
but five subsequently died of their exposure. Only seven of a crew of 400 were
saved and Otto von Spee, son of the squadron commander was not among them.
Kent
had won her fight and avenged the Monmouth
but did take casualties. The
Nurnberg
had scored 37 4.1-inch hits but the design theories behind the armored cruiser
concept had been proven. The armor of
Kent
was never penetrated. The armored cruiser had come into being to run down and
destroy marauding commerce destroyers, and that is exactly what
Kent
had accomplished.
Emden
had already shown how dangerous and destructive the German light cruisers of
the Asiatic Squadron could be.
Kent
lost four dead and twelve wounded. The next morning the ship was enveloped in a
thick fog and the captain could not ascertain her location. She could pick up
radio transmissions but could not send them. All day
Kent
heard calls trying to raise her but could not respond. Since Sturdee did not
hear from
Kent
, he thought the ship might have been lost and made for her last known position
with his battle cruisers. It was not until the afternoon of December 9 that Invincible
received a message from
Macedonia
that
Kent
had appeared off
Port Stanley
. After repairs
Kent
was sent to the Pacific in the search for the sole surviving German ship,
Dresden
.
For three months
Kent
was engaged in her fruitless mission of seeking
Dresden
. The British intercepted a German telegram ordering colliers to rendezvous with
Dresden
300 miles west of Coronel on March 5, 1915 and
Kent
was directed to close this location.
Kent
found nothing but on the afternoon of March 8,
Kent
spotted the
Dresden
at the range of 12 miles. Again
Kent
took off in pursuit of the last surviving cruiser of von Spee’s squadron.
Kent
worked up to 21-knots but could not repeat the heroic performance of December
8. Undoubtedly her machinery was strained from her performance during the chase
of
Nurnberg
and in was unable to come to grips with the faster German cruiser.
Dresden
had disappeared over the horizon for an hour and as night descended with the
Kent
short of coal,
Kent
had to break off the chase. The next day
Dresden
put into
Cumberland
Bay
in
Chile
. The cruiser only had 100 tons of coal left and when told by authorities that
the ship had to leave in 24 hours and could not await colliers,
Dresden
’s captain decided he had no choice but to be interned by
Chile
.
Dresden
was still flying her flag at that location on March 14 when she was closed by Kent,
Glasgow and Orama.
Kent
came in from the east while the other two lighter ships came in from the west.
The British force had been ordered to destroy the
Dresden
, rather than see her interned and with no Chilean warships present, steamed
into Chilean waters to finish the German cruiser. At a range of 8,400 yards
Glasgow
opened fire on the anchored
Dresden
at 08:50, followed shortly after by
Kent
. The
Dresden
could neither fight nor flee, however, she did open fire at the overwhelming
British force. Within three minutes British shell strikes had so damaged the
Dresden
that she lowered her flag. Captain Ludecke of
Dresden
sent Lieutenant Canaris, later Admiral Canaris head of intelligence for the
Kriegsarine, in a boat to
Glasgow
to parlay. This was done just to gain time to allow the
Dresden
to be scuttled. In addition to haggling with Canaris, Captain Luce also had to
issue apologies to the Chilean governor because his boat had been fired upon by
the British during the short engagement with
Dresden
. In the meantime the German crew was transported ashore and sea cocks and
underwater torpedo doors on
Dresden
were opened. At 10:45 the forward magazine of
Dresden
exploded. As the ship settled by the bow, the German crew on shore cheered
their ship and the crew of
Kent
lined her rails and also cheered the
Dresden
.
The rest of the war had to be an anticlimax for the crew of
Kent
. The Counties were designed to be trade protection cruisers, a role in which HMS
Kent excelled. Larger armored cruisers were also designed for
fleet work. It was the bigger cruisers that suffered catastrophic losses at
Jutland
. Of the 35 armored cruisers built to seven designs, it is ironic that the most
successful of the breed would be one of the discredited Counties, whose lack of
any gun bigger than a 6-inch was ridiculed by Jackie Fisher and others. However,
the Counties proved their worth. Only Monmouth
was lost to enemy action and that was against a superior force. In marked
contrast none of the 19 RN armored cruisers mounting 9.2-inch guns sank anything
and eight of their number were sunk in action against the German Navy. The
Counties served everywhere patrolling the long sea routes of
Great Britain
and serving as convoy escorts.
Kent
destroyed one cruiser and took part in sinking another.
Cornwall
also took part in sinking another cruiser. After the war HMS
Kent was sold in 1920 and broken up. (History from: (The
Anatomy of British Seapower, 1940, by Arthur Marder;
Castles of Steel, 2003 by Robert K. Massie: Coronel and the
Falklands, 1962 by Geoffrey Bennett; The Naval Annual 1899,
1899, Recent Warship Construction by T.A. Brassey, Chapter VI; The Naval
Annual 1899, 1899, First Lord’s Memorandum by George J. Goschen First
Lord of the Admiralty; Naval Annual 1900; Naval Annual 1901,
The Past Five Years’ Warship-Building by Archibald S. Hurd; Naval Annual
1903;)
The Combrig 1:350 Scale
Kent
With their 1:350 scale HMS
Kent, Combrig has
released the only British armored cruiser commercially available. With the
review of the 1:350 scale Combrig Danton,
some commented that the Combrig Danton
looked like an enlarged version of the 1:700 scale Combrig
Danton.
Those statements were true but what was wrong with that? With the Danton,
I guess the metal deck plate patterns and funnel seams could have been included
with the detail on the 1:350 scale kit. For the
Kent
, it too can be seen as an enlarged version of the 1:700 scale Combrig
Kent.
Again, what is wrong with that? With the
Kent
there are ways in which Combrig
could have improved their 1:350 scale release over their 1:700 release. The two
areas that jump to mind involve hull side detail. The hull anchor hull hawse
could have been opened and more importantly is the detail of the hull 6-inch
casemates. As with the 1:700 scale version, the 1:350
Kent
comes with shutters closed, requiring the modeler to drill the location point
for the 6-inch gun barrel. In 1:350 scale it would have been better to have the
casemate positions open and to have included separate photo-etch shutters,
thereby allowing the modeler the option to build the gun positions with open or
shut shutters. However, that being said, I like the detail on the Combrig
1:350 scale
Kent
. As can be said with the Combrig
1:350 scale Danton, don’t hold your
breath waiting for some company to release an injected version of either class.
Hull
Detail
With British armored cruisers you’re guaranteed a high freeboard and the Combrig
Kent
doesn’t disappoint. The hull casting starts with a fine ram bow with a sharp
cutwater. As is true with all 1:350 scale Combrig
kits, there is a rein overpour extending below the waterline. This will involve
patient removal. The waterline is very clearly defined but don’t rush removal
of the overpour. Use a Dremmel to get close to the waterline but finish with
sandpaper. That way you won’t accidently cut into the actual hull and will
have a nice, smooth waterline. There are two hull anchor hawse to starboard and
one to port. The raised oval hawse fittings are present but as mentioned above,
the hawse interior aren’t opened. In 1:350 scale it would indeed have been
better to have these opened, allowing the modeler to insert the anchor stocks
inside the hawse fittings. The forecastle has a significant hull flare, which
reduced the amount of water taken over the forecastle. Just aft of the anchor
hawse is a secondary gun position with a cut in embrasure to allow end on fire.
The gun barrel locator hull will have to be drilled. Likewise when you get to
the signature double storey primary gun casemates the curving hull flattens to
for a cut-in embrasure. The gun positions have closed shutters. As mentioned
above, in 1:350 scale, it would have been preferable to have open gun positions
with separate shutters. Barrel locator holes will need to be drilled for all
casemate 6-inch guns. Amidship, the top of the hull has three notches on each
side at the locations of the secondary guns. The single main gun casemate has
the correct flat V shape, again presented with closed shutters. Aft is the
second double storey with closed shutters and a flat embrasure allowing for aft
end on fire and another single secondary gun embrasure at the very stern.
Deck detail is plentiful. The
forecastle has two open chocks on each side and a twin bollard fitting with the
correct hour glass profile, rather than the straight post profile as used by
other manufacturers. Of course the forecastle, weather deck and quarterdeck all
have wood planking but without butt ends. The flat metal anchor chain run
plates, going from the chain locker entrance to the deck hawse add a nice
contrast to the wooden decks. The deck hawse could have been cast with deeper
openings, so it will present a better appearance to drill them out with the hull
hawse to allow chain to run through to the anchors. Numerous locator holes are
present for the anchor windlasses and other separate forecastle fittings.
Between the forward barbette and superstructure locator well are two large cast
on fittings. One is a skylight with port hole detail and deck access fitting
with door opening wheel detail. Amidship deck detail centers around the three
deck houses that are the base for each funnel. Each one is different from the
others. There are seven deck coamings. One offset deck access coaming is to port
but the rest are centerline. Two small and one large deck access coming are on
centerline but the largest coaming has a mixture of access doors and ventilator
doors. As with the forecastle, opening wheels are cast on each hull access door.
There is one disappointment with the amidship deck detail, there are no coal
scuttles. Combrig normally provides
this detail. The fairly short quarterdeck has another four open chocks and two
twin hourglass bollard fittings and five more coamings.
Smaller
Resin Parts
British armored cruisers had minimal superstructure but there are still
plentiful smaller resin parts. The largest of these are the three funnels. They
have deep top openings, nice cap aprons but no segment band detail. Seam pipes
are separate parts. Both twin turrets have shallow locator holes for the
barrels, which are fine for resin barrels but if you get brass barrels, you may
want to deepen the holes. Each turret has gun commander cupolas. You’ll have
to remove a portion of the turret bottom stalks so that they will sit flush on
the deck barbettes. Another separate part is the base deck house for the bridge.
This horseshoe shaped part is fairly basic with porthole detail only. A thin
sheet of resin contains an additional eleven parts. Largest of these is the
decking for the aft superstructure. Cast on detail includes wooden planking,
flag lockers, solid rear facing bulkhead and thin side bulkheads, replicating
canvas covered railing. My preference is to remove the cast bulkheads and add
photo-etch railings, leaving it either open railing or covering the railing with
fine tissue or sheer cloth to replicate the canvas dodgers. Two smaller decks
cover the forward deck houses. Each of these is of a different pattern and does
not have the wooden planking, so apparently they represent metal decks. The
sheet has the deck that rests atop the horseshoe deck house.
Cast on detail on this part
includes deck planking and the armored conning tower. The conning tower has a
vision slit at the top and the crown has locator lines for the support lattice
on which rests the navigation bridge. The navigation bridge has the deck with
wings and deck planking and the pilot house. The deck house has crisp square
windows but the pilot house is solid, so the windows have to be painted. It
would have been preferable to have an open deckhouse to allow clear bridge
windows. Both the navigation deck and pilothouse deck have solid bulkheads
representing canvas covered railing. As with the aft superstructure bulkheads, a
better appearance will be had by removing the resin and replace with photo-etch
railing. From the photographs you can see the only shipping damage incurred in
that a part of the front face of the pilot house bulkhead is missing. For me at
least, this is of no consequence, as I would replace all of these bulkheads with
photo-etch railings. Six smaller parts on the sheet are the amidship catwalk,
two control tops, two control top crowns and an open platform. These parts allow
for a number of options because a different times, various members of the County
class had different configurations, such as control top forward and open
platform aft, control tops on both foremast and mainmast or control top forward,
control top aft (lower on the mainmast that the top on the foremast) and an open
platform above the control top.
Eleven resin runners contain the bulk of the smaller resin parts. The runner
with largest parts has three slopping funnel base aprons, four hull side strakes
and three nicely detailed anchors. Another runner has twelve excellent mushroom
vents in three different patterns, a balsa raft and two deckhouses with crown
door detail. These small deckhouses are placed fore and aft of the middle
funnel. A small thick runner has two outstanding deck winches. I like photo-etch
cable reels but their problem is cutting the hose reels to the right length to
fit inside the reel frames. Combrig
provides with their
Kent
a runner with separate cable reels in two patterns, so that you don’t have to
cut hose cylinders from plastic rod. This runner also includes seven small drum
ventilators, shaft skegs, binnacles and other navigation equipment. The fourteen
six-inch gun barrels occupy a runner on their own. The muzzles do not have open
barrels. Instead the barrels appear to have tampions, which were used to close
the muzzle from the weather. Secondary guns are on a separate runner. This
runner includes open deck guns with separate gun and cradle parts, barrels for
the four hull secondary positions as well as small deck ventilators. Another
runner has eight detailed searchlights. In my sample two of the searchlights had
broken off from the mounts but are easily reattached. The four windlasses, three
forward and one aft of a different design, are located on another runner. Lower
foremast and main mast tubes are on another runner. Boat davits are on a runner
but a few of these are warped. I have the waterline version of the
Kent
but it still came with a resin run of the rudder, shaft supports and
propellers. Although moot to me, it is worthwhile noting that the propellers are
not identical. Instead they have different blade angles on each propeller,
accurately reflecting the fact that the blades on propeller were canted in an
opposite angle from the blades on the other propeller to minimize torque. Each
of the fourteen ship’s boats are cast on their individual runners. Two of
these are steam launches in individual patterns with separate funnels. These are
very nice with cast on skylights, deck houses, ventilators, access hatches,
rudders and even coal scuttles. The open boats come in five sizes from the large
whaleboat to small dinghies. Each of these has thwart and bottom planking
detail.
Brass
Photo-Etch Fret
Combrig provides a photo-etch brass
fret of ship specific parts. The modeler will have to provide after market
photo-etch railing and inclined ladders, which is a must for this model. Most of
the larger brass parts are the various raised boat skids found amidship. Five
parts are navigation deck supports, three for the structure on the conning tower
crown and separate supports for each bridge wing. Ten triangular supports are
provided for the bottom of the control tops and open mast platform. Twenty boat
cradles in different patterns are also on the fret. The fret is rounded out by a
small cable reel, ship’s wheel and navigation map table.
Instructions
The Combrig Kent
instructions come on two back-printed pages. They are usable but could certainly
be better. Page one has an essential plan and profile, statistics and short
history written in English. The plan and profile is essential in order to
specifically locate various parts, such as the separate hull strakes. The
profile also serves in providing a standing rigging diagram. Page two is the
standard resin parts laydown. Page three has a laydown of photo-etch parts and
isometric view of initial hull assembly for the boat skids, catwalk and deck
edge boat positions with a separate inset for the rudder, shaft supports,
propeller, shafts and skegs. The last page contains the bulk of the assembly for
everything else. Separate insets have details for secondary guns, turrets,
tertiary guns, and a template for cutting mast yards. Always refer to the
profile and plan for attaching parts, which do not have locator holes.
Verdict
From 1898 to 1905 the Royal Navy designed seven classes of armored cruisers. In
less than a decade, in this period of armored cruiser mania, there were 35
British armored cruisers built. Ten of these were of the trade protection County
Class. HMS
Kent was one of these. With the Combrig 1:350 scale
Kent
, any modeler can build a resin and brass version of one of the victors of the
Falklands
.
 |
 |
_____________________________________________________________________________________________
|
|
|